Delaware Startup, California Problems: What Founders Need to Know About Hidden Legal Risks

When raising your first preferred equity round, the legal process can seem overwhelming. Among the most critical pieces you'll encounter is your Certificate of Incorporation—the blueprint of your company’s structure. Let’s break this down so you can confidently navigate this step in your fundraising journey.

What Is the Certificate of Incorporation?

You’ve probably dealt with this document before—it’s what officially set up your company when you incorporated. But during a fundraising round, the stakes rise. The Certificate of Incorporation will need to be amended to reflect your new investors' rights, preferences, and powers. Essentially, this document will now govern how investors interact with your company and protect their interests.

---

The "Quasi-California" Twist

Here’s where things get tricky for companies operating in California but incorporated elsewhere (like Delaware). If your company has a significant number of shareholders or operations in California, state laws may apply to you—even if your legal home is Delaware. This is known as being a quasi-California company, and it brings additional rules that could impact your financing round.

1. Cumulative Voting: A Minority Shareholder Power Move

In California, shareholders can pool their votes to elect directors through a process called cumulative voting. This rule empowers minority shareholders to influence who sits on your board. If your company is incorporated in Delaware but qualifies as quasi-California, you might face conflicting rules. Delaware law requires cumulative voting rights to be explicitly written into your charter. Without this, you could accidentally violate Delaware law.

💡 What to Do:

Add a cumulative voting provision to your charter if your company is quasi-California. But tread carefully cumulative voting can give minority shareholders more influence than you may want. Work with your legal advisor to weigh the risks.

2. Strict Rules on Distributions (Dividends and Stock Buybacks)

California sets stringent financial requirements for distributions to shareholders, like dividends or stock buybacks. Before making any distributions, you’ll need to meet specific financial tests to prove your company’s stability.

💡 Why This Matters:

California’s rules could make it harder to return capital to investors compared to Delaware. Directors also face potential personal liability for illegal distributions, adding another layer of complexity.

3. Indemnification Limits for Directors and Officers

California law places stricter limits on how much protection you can offer your leadership team

from legal claims. This may require updates to your charter or bylaws to ensure your directors

and officers are adequately protected—especially in high-stakes venture financing rounds.

4. Mergers, Reorganizations, and Asset Sales: Added Approval Steps

In California, certain deals (like mergers or major asset sales) may require:

• Class Votes: Each stock class may need to approve the transaction.

• Dissenter Rights: Shareholders could demand cash for their shares instead of accepting

the deal.

💡 The Bottom Line:

These rules may require additional voting agreements or fairness opinions to get a deal across

the finish line.

---

Why It Matters for Founders

Updating your Certificate of Incorporation isn’t just a legal formality—it’s a strategic move that impacts your investors, your leadership team, and your company’s future. By addressing these nuances early, you can avoid legal headaches, streamline the fundraising process, and build trust with your investors.

---

Final Thoughts

As a first-time founder, navigating these complexities can feel daunting. The good news? With the right legal guidance, you can structure your charter amendments to ensure compliance, protect your team, and set your company up for long-term success. Proactively tackling these issues shows investors you’re serious about governance and ready to scale.